Claude Opus 5 5 vs Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) — API Pricing, 150K Cache & Latency Benchmark
Side-by-side unit economics audit comparing Claude Opus 5 5 (claude-opus-5-5: Input $4/1M, Output $20/1M, Warm Cache Read $0.2/1M) against Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) (google/gemini-4-carbon:batch: Input $1/1M, Output $5/1M, Warm Cache Read $0.05/1M).
Activate 4-breakpoint prefix caching on Claude Opus 5 5 to cut input token costs from $4/1M down to $0.2/1M, or route async workloads via Batch API for 50% off.
Lock static system prompt prefixes on Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) to pay $0.05/1M warm cache rates instead of $1/1M uncached input, plus eligible startup cloud credits.
In Etuki FinOps telemetry comparing Claude Opus 5 5 (API ID: claude-opus-5-5) vs Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) (API ID: google/gemini-4-carbon:batch), Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) offers lower standard uncached input pricing at $1/1M tokens, while Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) leads in 10-turn 150K cache-pinned coding economics at $0.3175 per 10 turns (saving $1.1025 over Claude Opus 5 5). For latency-sensitive interactive agents, Claude Opus 5 5 delivers 55ms faster P90 time-to-first-token (420ms vs 475ms).
| Specification / FinOps Dimension | Claude Opus 5 5 (claude-opus-5-5) | Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) (google/gemini-4-carbon:batch) | Verified Advantage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Official Vendor API ID | claude-opus-5-5 | google/gemini-4-carbon:batch | UMCE 563-Registry Locked |
| 563-Registry & Routing Eligibility | is_known: true | routable: true | is_known: true | routable: true | Both Merkle Verified |
| Standard Uncached Input (/1M tokens) | $4 / 1M | $1 / 1M | Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) |
| Warm Prefix Cache Read (/1M tokens) | $0.2 / 1M | $0.05 / 1M | Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) |
| Standard Output (/1M tokens) | $20 / 1M | $5 / 1M | Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) |
| Context Window Capacity | 200K Tokens | 1049K Tokens | Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) |
| 150K Prompt × 10 Turns (Unpinned Cold + 2K Out) | $6.4000 | $1.6000 | Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) |
| 150K × 10 Turns Case A (100% Static Pinned) | $1.4200 (saves $4.9800) | $0.3175 (saves $1.2825) | Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) (-$1.1025) |
| 150K × 10 Turns Case B (90% Static + 10% Tail) | $1.9330 (saves $4.4670) | $0.4457 (saves $1.1543) | Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) |
| P50 / P90 First-Token Latency | 286ms / 420ms (88 tok/s) | 323ms / 475ms (82 tok/s) | Claude Opus 5 5 (-55ms) |
1. Full-Turn Rate-Card Substitution for Claude Opus 5 5: At an uncached input rate of $4/1M, output rate of $20/1M, and warm cache read rate of $0.2/1M, running 10 consecutive 150,000-token coding agent turns (with 2,000 output tokens/turn) without prefix pinning costs $6.4000. Locking 100% static prefixes (Case A: 1 cold turn + 9 warm cached turns + 20K total output) reduces 10-turn spend to $1.4200 (saving $4.9800); under a 90% static prefix + 10% dynamic tail workload (Case B), 10-turn spend is $1.9330.
2. Full-Turn Rate-Card Substitution for Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) & Winner Verdict: On Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) ($1/1M input, $5/1M output, $0.05/1M warm cache), 10 unpinned 150K turns cost $1.6000, dropping to $0.3175 in Case A and $0.4457 in Case B. Across every 10-turn 150K coding loop (including output tokens), Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) delivers an additional $1.1025 Case-A cost advantage.
Production Workload TCO: 25,000 MAU • 50M Tokens/Mo (50% Cache Hit) • 2,000 GB Egress
💡 Optimal FinOps Verdict: Deploying Google: Gemini 4 Carbon (batch) saves $213.00/month ($2556/year) at 25,000 MAU & 50M monthly tokens (80% input / 20% output split with 50% prefix cache hit rate).